Hedging, Broker, Correspondent, AI Governance, Compliance Tools; IMB's $11,615 Cost Per Loan
Some will say that governments are ideally situated to determine what is best for their citizens and then carry it out. Others will say that governments are ill-equipped for that and create failures, and that the private sector is much more efficient. Yesterday, in St. Louis, I walked to an historic example of a huge failure: Pruitt Igoe. 33 11-story buildings built in the early 1950’s, it was an attempt to satisfy the U.S. Government’s drive for affordable, urban renewal, integrated housing. (Sound familiar?) Finished in 1955, it was demolished about 17 years later due to vacancy, poverty, and crime, and filmed. What was the return on investment of that project? (I then treated myself to a chocolate malt at Crown Candy Kitchen, the oldest soda fountain in St. Louis.) (Today’s podcast can be found here. This week’s ‘casts are presented by Experian. From lenders and landlords to employers and consumers, Experian helps connect the housing ecosystem with the data and insights needed to make faster, confident decisions. Lead a smarter housing journey with Experian. Today’s has an interview with LexisNexis Risk Solutions' Kim Sutherland on the growing financial impact of AI-driven fraud and bot activity, and adaptive fraud prevention that balances stronger identity verification and risk detection with minimal customer friction and churn.)
Lender and Broker Products, Services, and Software
“By now, hopefully you’ve heard about MCD, the Mortgage Compliance Dataset. California officially announced it will be conducting exams through the State Exam System (SES) using MCD in 2027, and many more states will follow quickly. That means there’s never been a more important time to ensure your disclosures are in order, and you practice good data hygiene. Use the slower pace of holiday production to take a closer look at your files and make sure the data and the documents match with the results from your compliance testing software. If they don’t, or you’re not sure where to begin, Firstline Compliance would love to help. We’ll bring problems into clear view before they turn into your next state exam finding. Contact Ashley Bradford at 469-717-4232 to book a review before year-end.”
Six Principles for Successful AI Implementation in 2027. As you plan for 2027, your organization must have a plan on how to implement AI successfully and turn that investment into measurable ROI. Moving beyond pilots requires more than the right vendor, it takes a clear business strategy, trusted data, organizational alignment, and a plan for adoption. Drawing on insights from six respected industry experts, TRUE’s latest industry playbook, Six Principles for Moving AI from Pilot to Production, outlines the critical decisions lenders must get right to successfully implement, scale, and operationalize AI. Whether you’re launching your first initiative or expanding existing capabilities, these six principles offer a practical roadmap for making AI work in 2027 and beyond. Explore the Six Principles.
Calling ICE clients… now is the time to take advantage of our Super Early Bird registration discount for ICE Experience 2027 before prices go up on Nov. 20. Join your peers, technology experts and other mortgage industry professionals March 15 - 17 at the Wynn Las Vegas for educational sessions, networking events and expert-led hands-on training that can help transform your business today and for what’s next. Register today.
The next generation of mortgage lenders won’t compete based on who has the most AI tools. They’ll compete based on who has built the most intelligent enterprise. JazzX AI creates a general intelligence layer that orchestrates work across the full loan lifecycle without replacing the systems you’ve already invested in. With AI that reasons, learns, and adapts to your business - while keeping your team in control. JazzX helps lenders save $1,500+ per loan, improve loan quality, and close faster. Book a demo to see what proven AI and measurable outcomes can do for your operation.
“Your AI governance policy is only the beginning. When AI acts inside a mortgage workflow, your team still needs clear answers: Was it authorized? What was it allowed to do? Which authority applied? And where is the proof? Crittora controls AI at the moment it acts. Crittora’s CAAB solution evaluates whether an AI action is within defined authority before it reaches a tool, API, or mortgage system. Crittora Mortgage GSE Governance aligned Packs help turn those decisions into audit-ready proof. Control AI before action. Evidence after action. Less time chasing proof at audit. Crittora is the only AI security company with 100 years of combined mortgage experience. We are FRAME certified by MISMO, and ready to help you move your governance policy to production.
Wholesale and Correspondent Product News
NEW: NMLS LICENSING NO LONGER REQUIRED IN 38 STATES ON DSCR at Orion Lending! Take advantage of flexible 5/6 and 7/6 ARMs (including interest-only options) and 40-year amortization available with I/O to give your real estate investor clients more financing options. Plus, Orion is offering TWO pricing specials to help you stay competitive: 35 bps on COIN DSCR for eligible loans with 720+ FICO, DSCR ≥ 1, and LTV/CLTV ≤ 75 percent, or 62.5 bps on COIN DSCR. More flexibility, more options, and more ways to grow your business with Orion Lending. Not approved with Orion? Get Express Approved today and start submitting loans before the day ends. Plus, new brokers can take advantage of our 30 BPS Pricing Special on COIN DSCR.
Tax returns not telling the whole story? Logan Finance has two Open Road programs for that. Some of a broker’s best clients have substantial wealth but an income picture that doesn’t show it on paper. With Logan’s Asset Qualification program, their wealth is their qualifier: a 60-month depletion calculation on liquid assets qualifies primary-residence loans up to $3M at up to 80 percent LTV. Self-employed clients who would rather skip tax returns and bank statements have an option too: Logan’s P&L program qualifies on a CPA- or EA-prepared Profit and Loss statement, with loan amounts up to $3M. Both are part of Logan’s Open Road suite, which brokers can explore at LoganWholesale.com or by emailing bizdev@loganfinance.com.
“A challenging market can be easier to navigate with the right partner. As Thanksgiving approaches, we want to say thank you for choosing Newrez Correspondent. We’re grateful for your trust, your partnership and everything we’ve accomplished together in 2026. Now, let’s keep the momentum going. Our expanding product lineup gives you more ways to meet borrower needs, including Non-Agency Asset Depletion, Interest-Only options and Buydowns, competitive Closed-End Seconds and our new FHA and VA 3/1 ARM. Catch up on our latest product announcements or reach out to your Regional Sales Manager to find the right fit for your pipeline. And if you’ve explored our new web portal, keep the feedback coming. We’re listening. Thank you for growing with us. Here’s to a strong finish and an even stronger 2027.”
The TMBA Housing Summit
The TMBA delivered on its promise to “Bring together the mortgage industry, with realtors, bankers, builders, and politicians.” The discussion topics? Well, there was shifting politics on both the state and national level. How will Democrats rule and respond to the electorate? Obviously, affordability is important, but people don’t seem to know how to fix it: take steps to lower the cost of existing housing, negatively impacting current owners, or take other steps to help buyers, thus driving up the cost of housing beyond their reach.
At the lender level, title defects at the Agencies and credit score “modernization” were mentioned, as were rising insurance costs and income disruptions impacting servicing portfolios. Speakers discussed the midterm election’s results and the implications of going from French Hill to Maxime Waters chairing the House Financial Services Committee. We might see an increased capital gain exemption when you sell a house, perhaps in ROAD 2.0. We might see an FHA 2 percent capital cushion beyond losses which would allow for bringing down the mortgage insurance premium, would be paired perfectly with drop in LLPAs or gFee.
Speakers talked about compliance after the election, or, more accurately described, a return to compliance. It is well known that states have been hiring former CFPB enforcement attorneys. Lenders with an eye on being around for the long term continue with robust testing and monitoring programs.
Lastly, homebuilders are pushing back on land seller’s prices. Builders are asking, “How do we deliver quality product to homebuyers but at the same time simplifying the construction with less options for buyers?”
IMBs Bottom Line Turns Red
Our MBA reported that independent mortgage banks (IMBs) and mortgage subsidiaries of chartered banks reported an average pre-tax net production loss of $30 per loan they originated in the third quarter of 2026, compared to a net production profit of $973 per loan in the second quarter of 2026. “Staff reductions and other cost-cutting measures may accelerate the rest of this year and in the first quarter of 2027.”
Marina Walsh, CMB, MBA’s VP and Head of Industry Analysis, looked at the information in the MBA’s newly released Quarterly Mortgage Bankers Performance Report. “Average pre-tax net production income reached its lowest level for a third quarter since 2023. The results are particularly disappointing given that the third quarter has historically been the strongest quarter of the year. As mortgage rates increased over the summer, the industry struggled with lower production volume and escalating production costs. Average first mortgage loan balances declined for the second consecutive quarter, contributing to a decline of approximately $325 per loan in production revenues.”
Mortgage servicing income held up better than production. Per-loan net servicing financial income more than doubled in the third quarter as prepayments slowed and the valuation of mortgage servicing rights (MSRs) increased. Combining both production and servicing operations, 59 percent of mortgage companies generated a profit in the third quarter but at the lowest level since the first quarter of 2025. Without mortgage servicing operations, only 44 percent of companies would have been profitable.
The average pre-tax production loss was 4 basis points (bps) in the third quarter of 2026, compared to profit of 25 bps in the second quarter of 2026. The average quarterly pre-tax production profit, from the third quarter of 2008 to the most recent quarter, is 38 basis points. Total production revenue (fee income, net secondary marketing income, and warehouse spread) decreased to 331 bps in the third quarter, down from 333 bps in the second quarter. On a per-loan basis, production revenues decreased to $11,585 per loan in the third quarter, down from $11,909 per loan in the second quarter. Total loan production expenses (commissions, compensation, occupancy, equipment, and other production expenses and corporate allocations) increased to 335 basis points in the third quarter of 2026 from 308 basis points in the second quarter. Per-loan costs increased to $11,615 per loan in the third quarter. (For the mortgage industry as a whole, MBA estimates the purchase share was at 73 percent in the third quarter of 2026.)
Servicing net financial income for the third quarter (without annualizing) was $195 per loan serviced, up from $80 per loan serviced in the second quarter. Servicing operating income, which excludes MSR amortization, gains/loss in the valuation of servicing rights net of hedging gains/losses, and gains/losses on the bulk sale of MSRs, was $85 per loan serviced in the third quarter, unchanged from the second quarter.
Capital Markets
The TBA market doesn't move one position at a time, so why should your software? The Agile way to TBA is built for desks that need to move quickly, manage multiple positions, and stay ahead of market opportunities. With a fully customizable workspace, users can arrange widgets, monitor multiple coupons, and coordinate activity simultaneously without juggling disconnected screens or outdated workflows. Agile replaces the limitations of traditional single-leg processes with greater visibility, streamlined dealer communications, and automation that reduces manual coordination. The result? A more efficient desk capable of managing greater volume and complexity without adding headcount. More positions. Less manual work. One workspace built around the way you work. Discover the Agile way to TBA and see how modern technology is transforming the TBA workflow.
Market volatility continues as equity weakness fuels safe-haven demand. Despite continued economic growth, persistent inflation is eroding household purchasing power, with real wages declining 0.6 percent year-over-year through September while PCE inflation remains elevated at 3.6 percent and October gasoline prices surged 37 percent from a year earlier. Household finances are showing signs of strain, as real disposable income fell 0.3 percent in September and inflation-adjusted consumer spending was nearly flat, suggesting consumers are struggling to keep pace with rising costs. The economic growth we hear of is increasingly driven by business investment and other spending rather than stronger household purchasing power, creating a (growing) disconnect between positive headline economic performance and the financial pressures experienced by everyday Americans. Fortunately, the U.S. labor market remains resilient, with average monthly job growth of 137k comfortably exceeding the estimated breakeven pace of just 20k to 35k jobs, giving the Federal Reserve room to maintain restrictive monetary policy despite a meaningful slowdown in hiring. Unfortunately, U.S. homebuilder confidence has fallen to a 14-year low, with the headline index and all major components declining as high mortgage rates, persistent inflation, elevated construction costs, labor shortages, and hesitant buyers weigh on the housing market. Approximately 2.5 million purchase loans are expected to be closed in 2026, 26 percent below the 3.4 million annual average from 2016–2019. And that is despite relatively stable dollar-based purchase MBS issuance, evidence of just how much inflation-adjusted housing activity remains significantly depressed. Today’s economic calendar kicked off with mortgage applications from MBA, which fell 2.3 percent for the week ending November 13, as rising Treasury yields and renewed expectations of Federal Reserve rate hikes pushed the 30-year fixed mortgage rate to a three-week high of 7.35 percent. Higher borrowing costs weighed on both purchase and refinance activity, with purchase applications down 18 percent year-over-year and refinance applications down 54 percent year-over-year, signaling continued pressure on housing demand.
We’ve also received October Housing Starts (up, but with a back-month revision down) and Building Permits (-7.0 percent). Later today brings October Pending Home Sales, weekly crude oil inventories, the October FOMC Minutes, and a Treasury auction of $16 billion 20-year bonds. We begin the day with Agency MBS prices nearly unchanged from Tuesday’s close, the 2-year yielding 4.83, and the 10-year yielding 5.11 after closing yesterday at 5.10 percent.