MBS RECAP: Gains Largely Intact After Wild Ride; Pre-NFP Conundrum
By:
Matthew Graham
•
MBS Live: MBS Afternoon Market Summary
Do markets know something that we don't know? That's a tempting question to ask after witnessing what was probably the most significant global market movement given the amount of attention and explanation it received. All the normal exchange of behind-the-scenes chatter were shockingly devoid of commentary and attribution. When currencies first started swinging, anyone who pointed it out was forced to rely on the "technical break" explanation in USD/Yen. Indeed, there was a technical break there (and in Treasuries), but there was a lot more going on, and none of it lept off the page in the same way the currency gyrations did. Pleasantly, we're left with a day where Treasuries only managed to drop about 2bps by the close, despite solid gains remaining intact for MBS. Priced did fade from the highs and a few lenders did reprice for the worse, but we're 11 and 14 ticks higher on Fannie 3s and 3.5s respectively and have held ground quite nicely after coming off the highs. This definitely has the feeling of "something different" for MBS, but we'd expect that to be the case with a convincing move below 2.10 in 10yr yields. Bottom line: Markets don't know anything you don't know, and in fact, the rapidity of today's move combined by the lack of coverage confirms that utter nervousness precedes tomorrow's NFP (something we've not been alone in suggesting). It looked like a game-changer, but it's not. 10's closed within the realm of their pre-NFP range (over 2.07 and under 2.22), and we're left with MBS a little less sickly-looking as a fringe benefit. The entire fate of the universe could still be at stake with a big enough break from consensus on tomorrow's jobs numbers. Trading levels seem to be pricing in a miss to the tune of 30-50k (June NFP's have missed big for the past 3 years) so this suggests extra caution tonight in that it will take an even worse number to cause a pessimistic view relative to expectations (in other words, an 'as-expected' report tomorrow may be taken as a "win" for risk, and a negative for bond markets).
MBS Pricing Snapshot
Pricing shown below is delayed, please note the timestamp at the bottom. Real time pricing is available via MBS Live.
|
|
|
||||||||||||
Pricing as of 4:04 PM EST |
Afternoon Reprice Alerts and Updates
Below is a recap of instant Reprice Alerts and updates issued via email and text alert to MBS Live subscribers this afternoon.
2:49PM :
ALERT ISSUED:
Negative Reprice Risk Kicking in at Current Price Levels
The 'price leader' just repriced. We have a band of prices set up on the chart on the dashboard from 100-23 to 100-20 that we'd consider to be the first stages of the negative reprice risk zone for lenders that repriced at the highs. Fannie 3.0s are currently in that zone at 100-22 and hit 100-21 moments ago.
ALSO, keep in mind that lenders are probably taking a lot of locks right now and some of them have, in the past, been more aggressive to reprice for the worse in such cases. This afternoon feels like a prime opportunity for pipeline control reprices, so stay on guard regardless of MBS Price action, especially if you know the lender has a past precedent of such pipeline control reprices.
ALSO, keep in mind that lenders are probably taking a lot of locks right now and some of them have, in the past, been more aggressive to reprice for the worse in such cases. This afternoon feels like a prime opportunity for pipeline control reprices, so stay on guard regardless of MBS Price action, especially if you know the lender has a past precedent of such pipeline control reprices.
1:42PM :
Global Currency Implosion Slings MBS Through The Roof. Positive Reprices Galore
For a day that looked as if it was merely "to be endured" for weary bond markets ahead of NFP, it's turned out to be the most significant rally of the week, nearly matching May 29th's barn-burner. To make matters more interesting, there is no singular event to "blame" for the positivity (and as far as we've seen/heard it's increasingly likely to end up being chalked up to team effort of factors)
Here's a list of some of the potential factors with brief discussion to follow:
- Dollar/Yen reached a critical support zone in the 98.8 zone, and has been trading in the same sort of 'stair-step" pattern all year without meaningfully "stepping back down." 98.8 was the line of demarcation suggesting the first such step down could be in process. Once that technical zone was breached, USD/JPY launched into it's biggest one-day move in several months.
- Eurodollars followed the move (both currencies strengthening vs the dollar). Euros had their own reasons for strengthening (Draghi press conference further supports the notion that the EU won't print money. Euro likes...) but those same reasons suggest tough roads ahead with deleveraging and economic weakness.
- This putting together of 2 and 2, was a slow realization for market watchers as big trades started to pepper the US Treasury complex, which was already in "buy first, ask questions later" snowball mode.
- The snowball got a major push from 2.06/2.07 being broken in 10yr yields, a significant entry point to an even more significant technical zone stretching down to 2.04, and ultimately 2.0, even. The latter was effectively 'tested' today as 10's hit 1.999 for a second or two, but 2.04 looks to be the modal floor. Technicians will take note of yield levels at 3pm to assess longer term trend changes, but would ultimately need tomorrow's action to confirm them anyway.
- MBS Joined in the snowball!!! We've been talking incessantly about the disturbingly wider spreads in MBS and how the cart can lead the horse when MBS are weak enough (convexity selling in MBS dragging down prices in Treasuries), and now the REVERSE is happening today. We've discussed 2.10% in 10yr yields as one line in the sand, below which MBS have tended to look more optimistic. So the good times were already rolling for mortgage markets even before the bigger swing heading into the noon hour.
- Once the bigger swing hit, "more of a good thing" for MBS turned out to be just that, and the rally kept pace astonishingly well (in fact, this is one of the only instances where you'll see little old mortgage markets outperform a global risk reversal snowball's effect on Treasuries. Mark your journals!
- Speaking of global risk reversal snowballs... Yeah... that. It's not fun or glamorous, nor does it make for sexy media headlines the way a big piece of data does, but these snowballs can do this. The longer they continue without great explanations, the bigger they can get, further confounding attempts to explain them. To this end, the words in this morning's opening update, (published 2 hours before the crazy swings) are now unbelievably relevant:
"There's no remaining significant economic data today, leaving tradeflows (jockeying for position and BASING TRADING DECISIONS OFF THE OBSERVATION OF OTHER TRADES) and technicals (TRADING BASED PURELY ON TRADING LEVELS, WITHOUT REGARD FOR ANY FUNDAMENTAL DATA) to guide the price action for the rest of the day."
Sometimes the clearly delineated scapegoat for these kinds of moves just doesn't exist. I know that's a tremendously unsatisfying answer in what seems like a world of mathematical decisions and correlations, but it happens. Think of it like a murder case with overwhelming circumstantial evidence yet no murder weapon. Most of the circumstantial evidence is listed above, but the case isn't closed until tomorrow's witness is called to the stand at 8:30am (meaning that NFP could either confirm everything that just happened, or reinforce the 2.04-2.07 pivot zone in 10's. Looks like we'll be up in the air until then, but not without tons and tons of positive reprices to consider beforehand).
Here's a list of some of the potential factors with brief discussion to follow:
- Dollar/Yen reached a critical support zone in the 98.8 zone, and has been trading in the same sort of 'stair-step" pattern all year without meaningfully "stepping back down." 98.8 was the line of demarcation suggesting the first such step down could be in process. Once that technical zone was breached, USD/JPY launched into it's biggest one-day move in several months.
- Eurodollars followed the move (both currencies strengthening vs the dollar). Euros had their own reasons for strengthening (Draghi press conference further supports the notion that the EU won't print money. Euro likes...) but those same reasons suggest tough roads ahead with deleveraging and economic weakness.
- This putting together of 2 and 2, was a slow realization for market watchers as big trades started to pepper the US Treasury complex, which was already in "buy first, ask questions later" snowball mode.
- The snowball got a major push from 2.06/2.07 being broken in 10yr yields, a significant entry point to an even more significant technical zone stretching down to 2.04, and ultimately 2.0, even. The latter was effectively 'tested' today as 10's hit 1.999 for a second or two, but 2.04 looks to be the modal floor. Technicians will take note of yield levels at 3pm to assess longer term trend changes, but would ultimately need tomorrow's action to confirm them anyway.
- MBS Joined in the snowball!!! We've been talking incessantly about the disturbingly wider spreads in MBS and how the cart can lead the horse when MBS are weak enough (convexity selling in MBS dragging down prices in Treasuries), and now the REVERSE is happening today. We've discussed 2.10% in 10yr yields as one line in the sand, below which MBS have tended to look more optimistic. So the good times were already rolling for mortgage markets even before the bigger swing heading into the noon hour.
- Once the bigger swing hit, "more of a good thing" for MBS turned out to be just that, and the rally kept pace astonishingly well (in fact, this is one of the only instances where you'll see little old mortgage markets outperform a global risk reversal snowball's effect on Treasuries. Mark your journals!
- Speaking of global risk reversal snowballs... Yeah... that. It's not fun or glamorous, nor does it make for sexy media headlines the way a big piece of data does, but these snowballs can do this. The longer they continue without great explanations, the bigger they can get, further confounding attempts to explain them. To this end, the words in this morning's opening update, (published 2 hours before the crazy swings) are now unbelievably relevant:
"There's no remaining significant economic data today, leaving tradeflows (jockeying for position and BASING TRADING DECISIONS OFF THE OBSERVATION OF OTHER TRADES) and technicals (TRADING BASED PURELY ON TRADING LEVELS, WITHOUT REGARD FOR ANY FUNDAMENTAL DATA) to guide the price action for the rest of the day."
Sometimes the clearly delineated scapegoat for these kinds of moves just doesn't exist. I know that's a tremendously unsatisfying answer in what seems like a world of mathematical decisions and correlations, but it happens. Think of it like a murder case with overwhelming circumstantial evidence yet no murder weapon. Most of the circumstantial evidence is listed above, but the case isn't closed until tomorrow's witness is called to the stand at 8:30am (meaning that NFP could either confirm everything that just happened, or reinforce the 2.04-2.07 pivot zone in 10's. Looks like we'll be up in the air until then, but not without tons and tons of positive reprices to consider beforehand).
11:51AM :
ALERT ISSUED:
MBS Hit Yesterday's Highs. Positive Reprice Potential Ongoing
Fannie 3.0s and 3.5s are both back in line with yesterday's highs as Treasury yields fall to test the evergreen pivot point at 2.07. Several positive reprices have already been reported and more are likely if we don't reverse gains in any meaningful way.
Live Chat Featured Comments
A recap of the featured comments from the MBS Live Dashboard's Live Chat feature, utilized by hundreds of industry professionals each day.
Ross Miller : "REPRICE: 3:57 PM - NYCB Worse"
Tom Schwab : "REPRICE: 3:02 PM - Flagstar Worse"
Steve Chizmadia : "As always. Great alert and warning MG. "
Phillip Mangham : "REPRICE: 2:46 PM - Provident Funding Worse"
Matthew Graham : "New chart analysis posted for the 30YR FNMA 3.5.
Load Chart"
Load Chart"
Ted Rood : "Well you know it's not going to get any better rest of day, Curt.....unless you're floating thru NFP, why wait?"
Curt Sandfort : "my lender repriced at 12.25 EST, how many ticks can I slide before I see a reprice worse?"
Matthew Graham : "It's all well and good for me to say I was staring at my JPY chart with my head tilted and eyebrow raised, but Vic put the meat on the table!"
Matthew Graham : "Still want to give credit to Vic for calling out JPY before anyone."
Tom Bartlett : "with MG doing his usual awesome job of ferreting out the underlying murk!"
Tom Bartlett : "It is not NFP related TB it is dollar collapse related with many other overtones that remain a bit murky and mysterious!"
Matthew Graham : "Doh! that reminds me TB, I was going to put that in the headline... Something about "Very Small Move in US Bond Markets" but couldn't think of a way to qualify the statement in the space afforded by the title. Basically, the point was going to be that it was a small move compared to global currency markets. I started thinking "global currency implosion," one thing led to another, and the title became the title. "
Timothy Baron : "Maybe this was covered earlier, but I'm surprised at the large movement on the day before NFP. "
Mike Nondarakse : "Floating some borrowers who want to wait, otherwise everything is locked up."
Timothy Baron : "Floating for the moment but keeping a close eye on things."
Scott Rieke : "I'm floating - with clear disclaimer to client of the risk. Others I'll just lock"
Justin Dudek : "lock if it gets the job done"
Scott Rieke : "Who's floating, who's lock - at this point now"
Matthew Graham : "I'd give MBS a bit of a wide berth here. Notice the little hitch in prices at noon. Below that, and it's worth talking about the retracement, but anywhere above is just gravy"
Matthew Graham : "The most surprising thing I could imagine would be for the highs of that move to hold for the rest of the day"
Jason Anker : "4 & 3.5 holding up just fine. 3.0 matter anymore?"
Matthew Graham : "the entire universe of risk bounced at 12:27 and has slowly ebbed back in the other direction. "
Tom Bartlett : "it is narrowing down to a point that should break one way or the other soon. coiled spring."
Kunal Khanna : "The more we talk of this rally the more it loses steam..shhhh"
Roland Wilcox : "USBHM 2nd reprice for better"
Roland Wilcox : "REPRICE: 2:03 PM - USBank Better"
Ira Selwin : "100-03 at 9 am don't see how we could be near bleeding"
James Barnes : "stop the bleeding please"
Raul Lopez : "Frenzy slowing down?"
Nate Miller : "REPRICE: 1:50 PM - Caliber Funding Better"
Raymond Daley : "REPRICE: 1:46 PM - 360 Mortgage Better"
Read what our user's have to say about MBS Live on LinkedIn.
» Start a two week free trial of MBS Live.